The Power of Storytelling: How Nonprofits Turn Narratives into Engagement

Written By Avery Burns

Written By: Lilly Easom’ 25, English Major at the University of Delaware

Nonprofits are designed to serve a mission, like feeding the poor, promoting the arts, improving literacy, or fostering youth development. Making an impact isn’t just about doing good work, it’s also about communicating that work in a way that drives people towards taking action.

Storytelling is one of the most powerful tools nonprofits use to inspire, engage, and drive support. A well-told story can turn a passive observer into an active advocate. While data and facts are important, as they show the amount of impact a nonprofit makes, stories prove why that impact is valuable and evoke emotions to help connect people to a nonprofit on a deeper level.

In this blog post, I’ll explain how storytelling is one of the most powerful tools a nonprofit can use, and I’ll include some tips for writing your own nonprofit story.

Why Storytelling Works

Sets you apart

Storytelling reveals what sets your nonprofit apart from others (Euler). There are over a million different nonprofits within the United States, which means people have plenty of options of where to invest their time and money. To set your nonprofit apart, you may want to draw upon what your organization has experience in. Who exactly has your nonprofit helped? And how has receiving that help made a difference in the recipient’s life?

Humanizes your mission

Nonprofits often tackle complex issues, such as poverty, education, healthcare, or justice. Storytelling brings these causes to life by focusing on the individual experience, making abstract problems feel more relatable.

Stories stick

There’s a reason why we always remember the stories we were told as kids. Stories resonate more with audiences, and the facts prove it. According to Jennifer Aaker from the Stanford Graduate School of Business, “stories are remembered up to 22 times more than facts alone”. By combining both facts and stories, nonprofits inspire people intellectually and emotionally.

Amplifies voices

Nonprofits often serve underrepresented communities. Nonprofit storytelling offers these communities a platform to speak about their experiences in their own words.

Shows impact

Advocates want to know that their contributions make a difference. Stories are a great way for nonprofits to show the before and after of someone helped by their program. Stories like these make the advocate feel confident about their contribution, and help the organization build trust with future advocates.

Tips for Telling a Great Nonprofit Story

  • Focus on one person—even if the organization helps thousands, it’s best to zoom in on a single, personal story.

  • Keep it authentic—use the person’s own voice through quotes, interviews, or even have them narrate a video.

  • Show visuals—including photos or videos of the person, their environment, or moments of transformation can help deepen the impact.

  • Use the classic story arc:

    -Beginning: introduce the person and their situation

    -Middle: explain the challenge they faced

    -Turning Point: demonstrate how the nonprofit played a role

    -Ending: show the positive change and their future outlook.

  • End with a call to action—guide the reader to a call to action that fits the moment, like “Donate here”, “Share this”, or “Join now” (Nonprofit Storytelling)

It’s important to remember, storytelling isn’t just a marketing tool. Through narratives, nonprofits honor the people they serve, raise awareness, and inspire real change. So whether you’re part of a nonprofit team or simply want to support one, remember: stories move people and people move the world.

Works Cited

Avery Burns
Previous

The Future of Agriculture: How Delaware Nonprofits Feed the Community
Next

Gen Z Isn’t Selfish; They’re Just Trying to Survive